The Dental Billing Podcast
Dental billing is not data entry. It's the difference between a practice that collects what it earned and one that writes it off and calls it the cost of doing business.
The Dental Billing Podcast is hosted by Ericka Aguilar and Jen Lyman, RDH. Ericka has been a dental biller since 1998 and has taught billing in 31 states and Mexico. Jen came out of the operatory and now runs Lyman Revenue Solutions, handling both dental and medical billing. One of us knows exactly what the carrier is going to do with your claim. The other one knows what actually happened in that chair. You get both.
Every week we break down denials, appeals, coding, and the carrier behavior nobody warns you about, in plain language, with real sources. We teach the law before the codes, because a code doesn't win an appeal. Knowing what that carrier is legally required to do wins the appeal.
If you've ever been told you're "just the biller," this show is for you. Downloads in 114 countries and counting. Bring your coffee and your worst denial.
The Dental Billing Podcast
Stop Treating Patient Credits Like Free Money
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Credit balances look harmless on a ledger, but they represent money we owe to patients or payers and they can turn into a major risk if we ignore them. We break down how to audit credits correctly, avoid accidental giveaways, and stay compliant with refund rules and unclaimed property laws.
• Defining a credit balance as a liability rather than revenue
• Separating the credit balance report from accounts receivable for a true picture of risk
• Auditing one account step by step using the family ledger, the first negative transaction, and EOB comparisons
• Why we never refund directly from the report without verifying the cause
• The six common credit types and the correct action for each
• Handling Medicaid and Medicare overpayments with urgency and documentation
• Managing prepayments and deposits by linking them to treatment plans
• Using due diligence letters, dormancy rules and state reporting for unclaimed property
• Reducing audit risk and preventing practice sale delays with clean records
• Building a monthly workflow, assigning ownership and tracking ageing and totals
Share this one with your office manager and your CPA & always seek legal advice regarding your states laws regarding unclaimed property and credit management.
End of year billing department audit - click here!
Want to know how much treatment you have sitting on the books? Schedule a consultation with MaxAssist here:
https://maxassist.com/thedentalbillingpodcast/
Grab the FREE End of Year Revenue Push Playbook Here:
https://link.captivationhub.com/widget/form/rHoSnbSvVMeFH4V2GFsf
Get your Dental Billing Toolkit Here:
https://www.dentalbillingdoneright.com/the-dental-billing-toolkit
Download "The Most Underused Codes in Dentistry - And How to Get Them Paid" checklist here:
Schedule a billing chat with Ericka:
https://calendly.com/ericka-dentalbillingdoneright/30min
Email Ericka:
ericka@dentalbillingdoneright.com
Email Jen:
jen@dentalbilli...
Why Credit Balances Get Ignored
SPEAKER_00Good morning, friends. This is Jen Lyman, one of your hosts of the Dental Billing Podcast. As you can tell, it has been so crazy around here with Erica and I that we are just so busy trying to get everything ready for you guys. But we had a few things come up this week that I really want to talk about as we get towards the end of the year. So every practice management system has a credit balance report, right? And in most offices, nobody wants to open it. And maybe the doctor doesn't even know how to open it or what to manipulate within the report in order to get that report of just credits alone, not your AR, only credits. So I do want to walk through kind of how we audit credits when we're looking at a larger practice that maybe needs to minimize credit risk. Okay. And I'll tell you why I say it like that in just a second. So I want to tell you about the first time I ran a credit balance report for a new client. Now, this was, oh man, thousands of accounts and it was hundreds of thousands of dollars in credits. And the thing that caught me was the office manager looked at that number and they were like, oh, those aren't real numbers. That's just how the software shows it. I've heard that time and time again, and I know Erica has as well. And she was right about some of them. That is the way that it was posted. But some of them were posting errors, a payment on the wrong family member, wrong date of service, a write-off enter twice. They weren't even real money. Sometimes it was just a discount that the doctor had applied out of the goodness of his art because it's a self-pay patient and now the balances weren't matching, and they just assumed that this was a patient credit. So an insurance company can also be paid twice, as you guys know, or there is not coordination of benefits. So there's a lot of different scenarios where a credit is incorrect. Now that money isn't the offices. And that's something that really I really want to hone in on today is that credit balances are not your buffer for your practice. If you run your credit report and it is more than your patient balance report, remember to separate the two. We don't want them combined. If it is more than your balance report, you are in the red. So if your credit report shows 300,000 negative balances and that is only credits, and then you go and run your AR balance report and it's 200,000, you are in debt to your patients at negative $100,000. Those balances need to be audited so that they can be reviewed for accuracy. And it's just going to be me today. Erica is traveling for a couple fun things. So there's a couple things I wanted to go over before we start. First, full disclosure, I am not a lawyer or an accountant. So I do want to say that right off the bat. Anything that I say is related to my experiences, my experiences only, and related to dental billing only. So anything you have a question about, please do not email me about these things. These will be for your lawyers and your CPAs, but they're great questions to start asking as we head into the last few months of the year. Second, this episode mostly is for Oregon because I live here. I know most of the dental billing laws around here and unclaimed property, I'm very familiar with here as well. And the Oregon Report, the Oregon Unclaimed Property Report is actually due November 1st, which is about a month from now. So if you're in Oregon and you've never filed one, stick around because we need to talk about that. So here's where we're going.
Credit Balances Are Not Revenue
SPEAKER_00First, what a credit balance actually is and why it's the patient's money or the insurances, not the practices. Then we're going to talk about how to audit one account step by step. Then the six kinds of credits and what to do with each one. Then unclaimed property law, dormancy, due diligence, reporting in which state gets the money. And then the monthly routine that keeps this report from ever getting to negative $300,000 ever again. Okay, so let's start with what a credit balance actually is. A credit balance means the account has received more money than it owes, and the patient or the payer has paid more than the actual charges due and were billed out. So here's a sentence that I really want everybody in your office to be able to say a credit balance is a liability, it is not revenue, and it is not a buffer. It's money you are holding for somebody else, whether that be the patient or the insurance company. That is where offices go wrong all the time. I see it. The credit shows up in the software, it just sits there. And even, you know, if we're doing insurance billing and we send you a credit report after we've posted payments, those credits should be called on and dealt with immediately, as if they are a balance that you are going after. So it feels like a lot of practices think that that's their own money. Like it got deposited, it's in their bank account, it's paid. I mean, let's be real, it's already been paid for payroll. But on paper, it still belongs to the patient or the insurance company until you apply it to a real charge or give it back or let the patient know that they have that balance or that credit balance. What do they want to do with it? And there's another problem that we need to talk about too. Some are posting mistakes. I would say probably 50%, if not more, are posting mistakes that make it look like the patient overpaid when they actually didn't. If you refund those, you're giving away money that was actually owed to you. So the first rule of credit balances is never refund from the report. Don't ever look at your refund report, your credit report, and say, okay, I need to refund $300,000. That's not what I'm saying. You don't look at a list, see negative $300,000 and cut a check. That's impossible. You open an account, you figure out where it went wrong, why the credit exists every time, and then you make a plan to refund those amounts for the patients or the insurance companies, however your practice sees fit.
How To Audit One Account
SPEAKER_00So I want to talk about how to audit an account. Here's a process for one account. Once you've done it, gosh, a hundred times, 20 times, it takes about five minutes. But we do need to make sure that there's a couple things that we're looking at specifically. So step one is look at the whole family ledger, not just the patient. Maybe a payment was applied incorrectly to a different patient, and we just need to reallocate the credits to a different service that is still outstanding. Step two, find where the credits started. So scroll all the way back in the ledger until you find a negative running balance or transaction that pushed the account into that negative or into that red credit balance. And was it a payment? Was it an insurance check? Was it an adjustment? Start there. If you can't go back 10 years because your patient's been with you for that long, just start there. Okay. The third step is going to be to compare every insurance payment to its EOB. So did the posted payment match the EOB line item for line item? Were the PPO write-offs adjusted correctly, or maybe even twice? Did the insurance pay a claim that was already paid? Is this a duplicate payment? Do we need to ask the insurance company to send us a refund request letter? Does it need to be auto-deducted? There's a lot of different things that we need to look at with this. Step four is check for open treatment. Is there a treatment plan with a prepayment attached? Is the patient scheduled? If they're not scheduled, let's get them scheduled so we can use that credit before the end of the year. Step five is decide which kind of credit it is. So there are six kinds of credits. Each one has a different answer, and we'll go through them kind of in the next section here. But there's a lot of different ways that a credit can happen. Step six is document what you found and what you did. So redundancy is key in dental pilling. Notes, notes, notes. Put a note on the account, credit caused by duplicate posting of Delta Dental Payment on Data Service 31426. Reverse duplicate payment account now balances at zero. And then your initials. Six months from now, when somebody asks why that credit disappeared, so we need to be able to back that up with notes. And the last step here matters more than it sounds with the notes, because when a state auditor or a payer asks, what happened to a credit? I think it was a posting error, won't work. So we need to have a detailed notes with the date that we looked at it, the date it was corrected, what was wrong, the data service, and the reason behind it so that we can back up what we're doing. I guarantee you, as you're looking at credit reports and fixing all of these things, it is going to look like a complete disaster and your brain is going to be mush, but those notes will save you. So I want to get into the six kinds of credits as well.
Six Credit Types And Fixes
SPEAKER_00Every credit you find is going to be most likely one of these six. We'll go over kind of what to do with each one. So number one is posting errors. This is a false credit. The money was never overpaid in reality. It just looks that way because of how it was posted. So payment was on the wrong family member. We've talked about this one a lot. A write-off was posted twice, a discount was given, an insurance payment posted to the wrong data service. Fee entered was too low to the fee schedule. What you do with this is you fix the posting, correct it, make sure you make notes because again, we're not deleting anything in a practice management software without proper notes. Again, redundancy is key, you guys. So we're going to fix the posting, move the payment to the correct services, reverse the duplicate write-off. No money actually leaves the office, and the credit will go down to zero because it was never actually a real credit. In most offices that I take over and Erica takes over, this is the biggest group by far. Sometimes it's half of the report, if not more. So I really want to hone in on this. And this is why you never ever refund from that report. Number two is going to be patient overpayments. This is the most common real credit in dentistry. It does still need to be audited, but it still happens the same way. You know, we give them an estimate, they paid their portion at the visit, and then insurance ended up paying more because we're at a network and we, you know, it was an estimate. We don't actually know how much they were going to pay. So now they've overpaid. What we need to do in this instance is refund the patient very, very promptly. Cut them a check. Now, a lot of offices also say, we'll just leave it on the account for her next visit. Can you do that? Sometimes, depends on your state law if you're able to do that. And in some cases, you may need written consent from the patient in order to keep that credit as a credit on their account. So what you don't do is decide for the patients and say, well, they have treatment coming up in January. I'm just going to leave this credit on the report. You need to call them and figure out what they want to do with that credit, inform them that they have a credit, make a note of that. Good practice and standard practice should be to refund the patient over payments within 30 to 60 days of finding them after all insurance claims are paid, reconciled, and audited for accuracy, whether your state requires it or not. It's just the right thing to do. It's the ethical thing to do. And a patient will gain more trust and rapport with you if you can just be honest about these things and not try to hide anything from them. Number three is going to be insurance payment, overpayments. This one's kind of an obvious one, but the payer paid more than they should have. Maybe it was COB, they paid twice, whatever that the case may be. What you do in this case is twofold. You can call the payer, confirm it was an overpayment. Maybe they don't do COB and they don't take that into consideration, and that money is the patient. So we just may need to make a note of that. If it is Medicaid, this is not optional and it is not slow. So if you are a Medicaid office, federal law does require providers to report and return a Medicaid or Medicare payment within 60 days of identifying it. Note the account, look up all of your Medicaid and Medicare patients, make sure that they are the ones that you go through first when you're going through these auditing reports. Keeping it past that can turn into a false claims act problem. If you bill Medicaid, government credits go to the top of your list every single month. Do not sleep on this step at all. Another thing here, too, if the overpayment is because the payer paid primary when it should have been secondary, we need to make sure that we're billing the correct one. We're notating it in the account that we're swapping the primary and secondary before we refund. So you're not left with a balance once the refund goes out. So swap it, bill primary first, get that corrected, then adjust for the secondary claim when they paid primary. Number four is prepayments and deposits. So this patient in advance for treatment, let's say they paid in advance for treatment and it hasn't happened yet. So this might be a crown deposit, an ortho deposit, down payment, whatever the case may be. A lot of offices pre-pay and pre-collect, which I love. But this is a legitimate credit. So while the treatment is still planned, you're holding it for work you're going to do. So just make sure that you link the prepayment. Most softwares have this. Link the prepayment to the treatment plan so that everybody can see why it's there and set a rule. If treatment is canceled or the patient hasn't been seen in X amount of days, let's say 30 days, 30 days, 60 days, some offices do six months. We need to make sure that there is an alert that we contact the patient, ask what their plans are to do with the treatment, and possibly refund them. Again, around Christmas time, if you tell patients, hey, we have a credit for you, most patients are thrilled and they want to pay for their Christmas presents. Let's be real. So prepayments are mostly where the really old credits come from, honestly, because people move, they change dentists, they never come back, they, you know, they end up getting an extraction instead of a crown, whatever the case may be, just make sure that you're auditing that and making a note of prepayments in a separate column on your auditing report so that you can keep track of that. Again, if it's allocated to a treatment planned procedure, that will come out of your credit report. So make sure that those are still audited so that you can check for accuracy. Number five, unapplied and unidentified payments. So the money came in. Nobody knows exactly what it was for. Maybe it was a payment posted to the account with no procedure attached, an insurance check with no EOB attached, a cash payment with a note that says from grandma. What you need to do in this case is investigate. Get the EOB, call the patient, look at the deposit record. And once you know what it's for, it becomes one of the other five. And then we need to address it. Number six is uncashed refund checks. So you did the right thing, you found the overpayment, we issued the refund, and the patient never cashed the check. Maybe they moved, maybe it went to in a drawer somewhere. We need to follow up with those and make sure that the patient either received it, we need to reissue, we need to void and reissue the check. It still belongs to the patient. So unchecked uncashed checks are one of the most common types of unclaimed property. There is. They go into the unclaimed property process we're about to talk about in just a second.
Unclaimed Property Rules For Credits
SPEAKER_00Okay, so next we're going to go into unclaimed property. This is the part that most offices have never actually heard of. I just want to talk about what it is and kind of how we as dental offices can report this and know what to do. So you did everything right when you did your credit report. We audited the accounts, right? It's a real patient overpayment. You sent a refund check and it came back undeliverable. You called, the numbers disconnected, you emailed and it bounced. What do we do with that money? We don't just say, oh, I guess that's ours now. We get to keep that. That's not the answer. And it's definitely not write it off to I have some offices that I've seen. They have like an income patient. We're just going to write that off to the patient. We're just going to put it in there. Every state has an unclaimed property law, and it says that money belonging to someone you can't find eventually goes to the state, which holds it for the owner until they claim it. That's what those search for your unclaimed property websites are for. Somebody's old dental credit may be sitting in there right now. So here's how it works in four pieces. You have dormancy, which is how long the property has to go with no contact from the owner before it's considered abandoned. For credit balances and uncashed checks, it's usually about three to five years. I know in Oregon it's three years, and payroll is one year. In Texas, for instance, the dormancy period for patient credit is three years. So the second piece is due diligence. Before you report the property to the state, you have to try to reach out to the owner. You have to verify accuracy. Usually means a letter to the last known address telling them that you're holding money that belongs to them and they need to call so they can claim it. If they don't claim it, they need to report it to unclaimed property. So in Oregon, a due diligence notice is required for property of $100 or more. And all of it has to be completed at least 60 days before the reporting deadline, which again is November 1st in Oregon, where I live. And I know every state is different. So make sure that you find out your due diligence laws and your reporting deadline for your state. So here's a practical tip I want to give you guys. The due diligence letter gets a surprising number of people to call once they know that they have money waiting. And a lot of them want it. So every credit you refund directly is one less item that we need to report. But we do need to have a plan for that because if we're only collecting, you know, let's say $50,000 a month in insurance money or in collections each month, we don't want to give out $50,000. We can't make payroll with that. So we need to be strategic. Okay, let's get real about this credit report. Let's make a plan. Every credit over $100 gets checked. Let's make a plan for this and then start notifying patients. Piece three of the unclaimed property is reporting and remitting. So once the property is dormant and you've done your due diligence, you'll file a report with the state and send the money to them. It goes off of your credit report onto theirs. You don't have to look at it again. So I do want to call something out about organ. Oregon requires negative reports in certain cases, meaning you file even when you have nothing to report. So that applies to active holders and to holders audited in the last five years. So check with the Treasury whether that applies to your office. The due diligence window, again, make sure that you know that so that you can be there for the deadline. Then we need to set up our calendar. So next year, the due diligence letters go out in the summer so that we can kind of space all these credits out in the right way. So piece four is which state gets it. So this one confuses some people, and I again consult a lawyer, especially offices near a state line. So the general rule, which goes back to a US Supreme Court case long time ago, is that the property is reported to the state of the owner's last known address, patient's address. If there's no address, it goes to the state where the holder is incorporated. For most dental offices, almost every patient lives in the same state as the office. So it's really simple. But if you're in, again, I'm in Oregon, if you're in Portland and half your patients live in Vancouver, which is 10 minutes across the border, which is Vancouver, Washington, some of your unclaimed property credits may belong to Washington. Your CPA can kind of help you sort through that.
Audit Risk And Practice Sale Problems
SPEAKER_00So now what gets offices into trouble? One is writing off old credits to income. This is exactly what unclaimed property laws prohibit. So the money still belongs to the owner, still belongs to the patient. You can't make it yours by making an adjustment. Old credit cleanup is what I've seen. Don't do that. Credit write-off, don't do that. We need to make sure that you are giving the patient what's theirs. Two, not knowing there's an audit risk. So states audit holders, meaning offices. And in an audit, if your records are incomplete, some states will actually estimate what you should have reported using sampling. They'll look at a sample of like dental records and apply the result across years. They can turn a few thousand dollars into old credits into a much bigger number, plus interest in penalties. I know Texas does that. They have interest in penalties as well. So this is a big reason to clean up your credit reports. Three, practice sales. If you work with offices that are being bought or sold, which we've worked with multiple this year, credit balances come up in due diligence. A buyer's accountant is going to ask what the credits are and whether the unclaimed property filings are Current. If they aren't, dentists who are looking at purchasing a practice, listen to this piece here. If they are not, it can hold up the sale or change the price for credit balances. Doctors, this really matters to you, even if you're not thinking about selling for 10 years. You need to make sure that this is clean.
Monthly Routine To Keep Credits Clean
SPEAKER_00So the monthly routine, what does this actually look like when we're looking at a credit balance report? Every month, I want you to run a credit balance report, same day, each month, like you run your AR report, sort by age and by dollar amount. Okay. We're going to work the government credits first. So Medicaid top priority, number one, every time. And Medicare if you have it. 60 days from when you identify it. Make sure that you have a running list of this that you are on top of your Medicaid refunds. Then work new credits, the ones under 30 days old. Once you have all the old ones cleaned up, we're going to work on the under 30 days old because we want to make sure that it stays clean. Most of them are fresh posting errors or fresh overpayments. They're really fresh in your brain. They're easy to fix, fast to fix, and everybody remembers what happened. So it's really easy to do. Make notes, make notes, make notes. Then take a bite out of the old ones. Okay, so 20 accounts a month. You'll be surprised how fast the backlog goes. And we need to make sure that we're auditing, confirming credit balances, and notifying patients. That is all part of the audit. Then we're going to refund patients within 30 days of confirming the overpayment. So refund payers with a letter, refund patients with a letter if they overpaid immediately. Keep an aging list of the credits you couldn't resolve to. So there's credits where you tried, couldn't reach the patient, uncashed checks. Again, that list is your unclaimed property list and it goes to whoever files that report on a yearly basis. Once a year, put the unclaimed property deadline on the calendar for your state. So we're going to work backwards. Again, for Oregon, it's November 1st. Due diligence letters out well before September. So for Texas, I would say like report July 1st, and then just know your deadlines for each state. Also track who owns this. In a lot of offices, credits aren't anyone's job. So they're just nobody's job because they don't bring in income. But a lot of times, we as the billers will find it and the office manager approves refunds, the doctor signs a checks, the CPA files the report. Write that down so everybody knows their part. It kind of needs to be like, you know, you have an OSHA officer, do the same thing. You have a credit officer, and they are the ones that check, know the deadlines, and get this done. And the number to watch is the total credit balances as a dollar amount. And how many accounts are over 90 days? Put it on the monthly report next to the AR. If it's going down, you're doing it right. I want to encourage you guys, make sure that you have this, you know how to pull your credit report and go through these steps that I outlined for you. In Eaglesoft, for instance, if you pull the AR report, you need to do negative 999,999 to negative 0.01. And that will give you all of your credits filtered, not including your balances. Know what the difference is between the two so that you can accurately balance
Key Takeaways And Staff Training
SPEAKER_00that. So let me bring this kind of all around for you guys and wrap this up. At the end, when an office has a credit balance report, they can trust, it creates trust with the patients and it creates that transparency that we are not trying to hide anything from you. This is what it is. And that's the entire point of a credit report. Your trust means you can refund quickly, find posting mistakes before they pile up, and answer an auditor's questions without panicking at all. Five things I want to wrap up with you. A credit balance is a liability. It's not revenue, it's not cushion in the bank. It's not money that you're holding for yourself and your staff and payroll and all those things. It's money you're holding for someone else. Secondly, never refund from the report. Open every account, find the transaction that created the credit, and document what you found. Third is know the six kinds of credits so that you can look back at this. So this posting errors, patient overpayments, insurance overpayments, prepayments, unapplied payments, and uncashed checks. Each one has a different answer. Money you can't return goes through your state's unclaimed property process. Dormancy, due diligence, report. Those three things. It never gets written off to income. Make it monthly. This is something you need to do every month, just like you do your insurance AR, just like you do your patient AR, 20 old accounts at a time. Government credits come first, top priority, and one person in the office who owns this project. Lastly, the six credit guide. The account audit steps and the deadlines are all in the show notes here. Share this one with your office manager and your CPA. I want to make sure that you guys are covered and that you have legal counsel going into this. Do not just write checks tomorrow. There is a lot of steps that need to go into this. Lastly, if you have staff that does not know how to use the practice management software that you are using for your practice, get the training. Okay. I have talked to so many offices that they prepay for services, especially Ortho. This is a big one. You prepay for services, then it never goes on the treatment planned service. And we just have a negative giant $1,000 credit or multi-thousand dollar credit sitting in the patient's account, looking like it's unclaimed property. Don't do that. Train your staff so that they know how important this is to your practice. And they need to know how to pre allocate treatment planned prepayments so that your balance report and your credit report is correct. Anyways, guys, I'm Jen Lyman, co host of this dental billing podcast. Thank you for listening, and I'll see you guys at the next episode.